McNew family scenario

(Last updated 8 Feb 2025)

1st gen   Shadrach McNew?                                            Mary Clemmons?
                                                       
                                                   
                                                     
                                                   
2nd gen   George McNew
(1765/70 - 1830s)
Elijah McNew
(1771/80 - 1830s)
   Lydia Hufstadler
(c. 1775)
   Edward McNew
(bef. 1775)
   Mary Foster
(bef. 1776)
   Charity Reynolds
(c. 1778-81)
   Martha Johnston
(bef. 1778)
   William McNew
(d. bef. 1748)
   Sarah Hayes
(abt. 1790)
   Nancy
McNew
(1799+)
   Elizabeth H
Bartley
(bef. 1800)
   Keziah
Smith
(aft. 1801)
                                               
3rd gen   Churchwell McNew (1797)
Henry McNew (1801)
Mary Williams (1802)
Elizabeth Lay (1810)
Melissa Steel (1815)
Elijah McNew (1805+)
William McNew (1816)
Sarah Deaton (1820
Elizabeth Thrower (1803+)
James McNew (1825)
      Susannah Knowles
Jeremiah McNew
Nancy McNew
Shadrach McNew
James McNew
George McNew
Jesse McNew
      Martha Morgan
William Reynolds
Ellender Reeves
Joseph Reynolds
Richard Reynolds
          Sarah Ricker
Dorothy Reeves
James A Hayes
Jesse Hayes
John Hayes
          Rachel Reeves
John Thomas Smith
and others..
                                                     



The Elizabeth Thrower DNA line:

Descendants of Elijah McNew have extensive DNA matches to descendants of an Elizabeth "Betty" Thrower.

Current speculation by this writer is that  Elizabeth Thrower was a daughter of Elijah McNew & Joanna Bowman.  Elijah and Joanna were married in 1801 but their oldest known son was born closer to 1805 so it very likely they had a child between 1801 and 1805 that is still unaccounted for.  Placing Elizabeth in that spot fills the gap and explains the DNA matches. 

Descendants of Elizabeth "Betty" Thrower could test this hypothesis simply be seeing if they DNA match to the Bowman family of Greene County, Tennessee.

Elizabeth may be the "Betsy McNew" seen on the 1830 Federal Census (TN, Sevier County) near Elijah McNew Jr.  On that census Elizabeth has three daughters. 

Lines highlighted in blue are ones that McNew descendants have DNA matches to.


1st gen   Elisabeth "Betty" Thrower?
(born 1803 per 1870 Census)
(born 1812 per 1860 Census)
                Thomas Thrower (1789)
and/or  Mr. Hess (c. 1800)
                       
                               
                     
    Elizabeth [Thrower or Hess]
(born after 1821)

"Have never seen her..."
Dinah [Thrower or Hess]
(born 1821 or 1831)
     Nancy [Thrower or Hess]
(born 1828 TN)

Md. Benjamin Mathews
(by 1849)
    Caroline [Thrower or Hess]
(born 1829-1834)  

Md. Jacob Bearden
(by 1854)
                         
                         
        John Thomas Bearden (1849 AL)
Caroline E. Scoggin (1853 AL)

Arenia M. "Rena" Stanfield (1854 AL)
Harriett Standfield (1857 AL)

Diana Scoggin (1868 AL)
Parasettie Florence (1869 AL)

Jefferson Davis Stanfield (1861)
(testified for "half brother" John T Bearden)
  Elizabeth Mathews Bass (1849 AL)
Mary "Polly" Donovan (1852 AL)
Sarah "Sally" Loyd (1854 AL)
Frances Mathews (1861 TN)
Pearlee Mathews Lee (1863 TN)
  Elizabeth Jane Bearden (1854 AL)
Jacob Simpson Bearden (1858 AL)
Richard Bearden (1859 AL)
Jefferson Davis Bearden (1860)
Lucinda Bearden (1863 AL)
America Bearden (1870 AL)
Ollie Bearden (1871 AL)
                   









 signature